Peter Manning NYC Reviews

The clothes fit fine, I guess, but the designs feel dated to me. Nothing really stood out, unless the goal was to make bland look expensive. For the price, I expected a bit more personality.

I ordered from the Peter Manning NYC site and overall it was fine. The layout is clean, and I was able to find the sizing info without too much trouble, which definitely helped since fit is kind of the whole point.

That said, some pages loaded slower than I expected, and the filters felt more annoying than they should have been. Checkout went through, but after I paid I didn’t feel totally confident right away, like I wanted more reassurance or clearer updates. Not a terrible experience, just kind of average and a little shaky after payment

The exchange was done really fast, no hassle at all. it took way less time than I expected, so that was dope.

I was really hoping these shirts would work out, especially after waiting longer than I expected for them to arrive. Unfortunately, the fit is just kind of weird on me, and the sleeves are still too long. Frustrating after all that waiting

The whole thing felt disappointing from the start. My order showed up in this plain, sad-looking bag, and everything inside was all wrinkled like it had just been tossed in there. For the price, I really expected nicer packaging and at least a little more care. On top of that, the product kind of works when it wants to, which just makes it even more frustrating. Definitely not the experience I was hoping for...

I stopped by the showroom hoping to get a better feel for everything, but the whole visit felt off from the start. The staff barely checked in or offered much help, and the sizing area was disorganized, which made it hard to know what I was even looking at. I kind of had that gut feeling early on that it wasn’t going to be a great experience, and by the time I left, I was annoyed.

I ordered a shirt and it just sat there for days before it even started moving, haha. It ended up arriving late, and when I reached out to support, they weren’t much help. Not the end of the world, but definitely annoying

I ordered my usual size, but the fit was just... not right. The shirt was way too tiny, and the pants felt weird too, like they were cut differently or something. I really wanted it to work, but...

I ordered a couple shirts from Peter Manning, and the fit was the best part. The sleeves hit where they should and the overall length didn’t feel weird or too long, which is usually my issue. I tried one on right after bringing in the mail, still holding my coffee, and was kind of surprised it actually looked right.
The only thing I noticed is that the fabric felt a bit heavier than I expected from the photos. It’s definitely not bad quality or anything like that, just warmer than what I had in mind for casual summer wear, especially on those sticky afternoons when even walking to the car feels like a chore.
Overall, I’m still happy with the purchase and would order again. Next time I’ll probably pay closer attention to the fabric details before picking colors, because the fit is good enough that I’d rather get it right than skip them entirely

Just a heads up for anyone considering these: they felt stiff on me, and after about an hour they started getting really annoying to wear. If comfort is your main priority, I’d probably look for something softer or easier to break in.

my order showed up just how I picked it. I got two shirts and a pair of pants, and the sizes, colors, and quantities were all correct, so there wasn’t anything weird to deal with.

The only reason I wouldn’t give it a full 5 stars is that the shipping email took a little while to update, so I kept checking more than I wanted to. But the order itself was accurate, and I definitely appreciate that.

I’ve picked up a few things from Peter Manning now, like a couple of shirts and some pants, and overall I’ve been happy with them. The fabric feels sturdy, not thin or flimsy, and the fit has stayed good even after washing, drying, wearing them to work, wearing them out to dinner, and just throwing them on for a normal weekend. The shirts still sit nicely, the pants haven’t stretched out weird, and nothing has started looking cheap after a few wears. I’m giving it 4 stars mainly because some pieces are definitely on the expensive side, especially if you’re buying more than one thing at a time, like a shirt, chinos, jeans, or a nicer button-down. But the quality is there, the clothes look clean and put-together, and I don’t regret what I bought.

I grabbed a couple of shirts the fit is so much better than regular brands if you’re on the shorter side. Like, I tried them on and felt personally attacked by how badly my old shirts fit compared to these. The quality is solid too, so no huge complaints there. That said, for the price, I was kind of expecting to be completely blown away. Once you add shipping and think about returns, it starts feeling a little painful unless there’s a sale. Really good shirts, just not exactly a steal.

I tried ordering a few basic sizes, and almost everything I wanted was already sold out. I checked back later like they kind of suggest you should, but nothing had changed. It’s frustrating because the site makes it seem like there’s plenty available, and there are all these vague promises about restocks, but you can’t actually buy much.

I checked out Peter Manning NYC because I was hoping to find some solid pieces, but the selection felt limited to me.
A lot of the styles kind of blended together, and I didn’t see much variety in colors or the basic stuff I was actually looking for. I get that sizing is a big part of the brand, but CHOICE matters too.
I ended up leaving without ordering anything. Just didn’t feel like there were enough options for what I needed.

Checkout worked fine for me, but it did feel a little clunky in a few spots. If you’re ordering, I’d just say take your time and double-check everything before submitting. Nothing major went wrong, but the process could definitely be a bit more streamlined.

I emailed them twice and still didn’t get anything even remotely helpful back... it was frustrating!!! I kept hoping someone would actually answer my question, but nope?? Not a great experience.

I’ve had a good experience with Peter Manning overall, mainly because the fit is so much better for me than what I usually find at bigger brands. Most shirts from places like J.Crew or Banana Republic end up feeling way too long on me, so it was nice to get something that actually looked right without needing alterations. Sizing was straightforward too, and the shirts looked sharp when they arrived. That said, after a few months, one of them started to fade and the collar didn’t hold its shape as well as I’d hoped. It’s not a dealbreaker, but considering the price, I expected it to hold up a little better compared with some cheaper options I’ve bought elsewhere.

I ordered what were supposed to be navy pants, but when they arrived, they looked almost purple. The site photos made them seem totally different, a little too different, so I’m wondering if they were edited or just not the same item. Disappointing

I ordered these pants based on the size and fit info on the page, but they ended up being far off. The fabric didn’t feel like what I was expecting from the description either. They’re not awful, but it’s frustrating when you’re just trying to buy what’s advertised. A more accurate description would be the fair thing to do